"Exploratory questions can quickly take people to the edge of their comfort zone. If they can tolerate the discomfort, this can be a growing zone, the edge of transformative learning. Monitor readiness, proceed gently, check out emotional reactions and give them your full, appreciative attention."
- Daphne Hewson and Michael Carroll
"There is often an absent but implicit standard when a person categorises someone or something. Visually depict goals/issues/assumptions and 'thicken' your understanding of the nature of each one. One way to explore assumptions is to shift a significant characteristic of the incident or participants and see how you respond to this. There's a vast literature of evidence-based theories and concepts that can be drawn upon to gain a richer perspective on an experience."
- Daphne Hewson and Michael Carroll
"Competing Commitments
In their book Immunity to Change, Robert Kegan and Lisa Lahey suggest we often don't put our commitment (espoused theory) into action because we have a competing commitment that's much stronger than our conscious commitment.
Frames
Once you see something in one way, it can be hard to notice other ways of seeing it, so it's sometimes helpful to suggest alternatives frames before starting to unpack assumptions that underpin the chosen frame.
Vision and Values
Surprisingly people often don't notice when there's a clash between their values and what they're doing or expected to be doing. They feel stuck and go searching for better techniques to solve the problem and then lose confidence when they don't work. Clarifying their values and vision and finding ways to align their work with them are potent outcomes from reflective practice.
Recurring Themes
Our assumptions are not usually situation specific, they tend to be generalised beliefs that apply in many situations... Noticing themes helps to unearth the deeper assumptions."
- Daphne Hewson and Michael Carroll
"Systemic Influences
Beliefs and actions are often influenced by the needs of the main people and institutions that are connected in some way to an incident.
The Family Gaze
Encouraging a kind of sceptical irreverence, liberation to think the unthinkable...but with humour and humility. Asking what your grandparents would say can elicit a rich parade of family stories that provides a light, non-blaming querying of beliefs and values.
Addressing Shame
Shame and other unsettling emotions block learning and need to be tended to as quickly as possible.
The Gaze
It's often difficult to answer the Gaze question because our beliefs feel like facts, not like ideas that have been culturally shaped. To counterbalance the influence of other's beliefs you can create your own 'team' that support yours and imagine them gazing over your shoulder, offering input."
- Daphne Hewson and Michael Carroll
"Processing Ruptures
Sometimes the rupture is a clue to issues that are impacting on someone's work, so attending to it not only heals the rupture, but also deep learning can be achieved.
Cultural Practices
Many of these Mini-Tools can elicit assumptions that are based on dominant power relationships. These questions are a sample of more specific ones for highlighting how everyday practice can inadvertently support privilege and oppression.
The Edge
These questions can be helpful when someone is at 'the edge'. The task is to be a mindful friend - a safe companion who gently encourages them to explore the threat to their worldview to the extent that they are ready and able."
- Daphne Hewson and Michael Carroll
"Critical Moments
Each of the moments is explored in detail to understand meanings and how they contributed to the unfolding events. There is often an implication that one had no choice or agency - as though the circumstances dictated their actions. These questions provide an opportunity to challenge this assumption and explore what underpins decision-making.
Kline's Incisive Questions
A powerful way to step around limiting assumptions. Identify the most limiting assumptions, check if it's true, ask for an alternative and what you would do if you knew it were true."
- Daphne Hewson and Michael Carroll
"Brainstorming
Open-ended, brainstorming questions are often the simplest and most effective in exploring meanings and unearthing assumptions.
Challenge Assumptions
Various methods (such as Socratic questioning, reauthoring or empty/two chair work) can be used to query one or more of the assumptions and explore preferred alternatives.
Elicit Preferred Action
It's often easy to see lots of things that could have been done differently and tempting to offer suggestions but a more helpful approach is to 'ask before you tell.' In the process of reflecting they often have more ideas about what they could do and are more likely to own and implement them."
- Daphne Hewson and Michael Carroll
Photo by Steve Carter on Unsplash
Created with ©systeme.io